Bald Head Island Nc main
Bald Head Island Nc two
Bald Head Island Nc three
Bald Head Island Nc four

"The Keep" - Best spot on Bald Head Island

0 available shares


target home price


cost per share

$4,512 / mo

estimated costs

$4,500 / mo

monthly income

Down Payment
Closing Cost
Reserve Fund Deposit
Total Cash at Closing
Co-own this home
4 bedrooms | 3.5 bath

5 Old Baldy Ct., Bald Head Island, NC 28461

4 BR, 3.5 BA, 2300 sf forest bungalow on quiet cul de sac walking distance to creek access, west beach and ferry (no tram needed!)
Completely renovated with new bathroom, appliances, paint in/outside, gym, storage, 3 carts, 5 bikes, all the beach/fishing gear and much more.

Had it for 5 years and love being there but can only get down halftime. Ready to sell 40-50% to thoughtful partner(s) with good co-owner agreement and open to flexible scheduling.

I'm interested
House Usage
  • 2 shares total
  • 26 weeks a year per share
About the Organizer

We are a soon to be retiring professional couple with 2 adult children (no grandkids yet!) visiting BHI for 30+ yrs. 6 years ago we bought half interest in this home and a year ago we bought the remainder and started upfitting inside and out. We can’t be on island enough and ready to sell a 40 or 50% share to one (preferred) or two coowners. We can be very flexible and creative in scheduling, use, expenses and purchases. We can manage (with partner approval) maintenance, repairs and improvements.(40 yr gen contractor & insurance broker). We are non smokers, and desire no outside renting or pet hair but will discuss. Our cul de sac neighbors are fabulous. There are 24 palms, 5 live oaks and 4 junipers on the .22 acre lot. There is a complete workshop, landscape equipment, storage facilities, and material/supplies/hardware onsite.There are established painted buntings pairs at our feeders. It is walk in and play ready with numerous carts, bikes, Paddle boards, kayaks, houseware, linens and every type fishing/beach gear. With the closest and best view of Old Baldy on the island , the 7 min walk to ferry and even less to west beach or creek access is amazing.There’s much more….

We are looking for a house that includes:
House Rules
  • No pets
  • No firearms allowed
  • No short term renting
Answered Questions
Ask a question
Home Inspiration
No listings added (yet)
Keep an eye on this space

Calculated Costs per Share

"The Keep" - Best spot on Bald Head Island
Bald Head Island, NC
Down Payment
Closing Cost
Reserve Fund Deposit
Total Cash at Closing

This is an estimate of the amount of cash needed when closing on the purchase of a property financed with a 30 year Mortgage at 8.0% interest rate.

Plum’s estimate includes 20% of the value of the house as a down payment, 6% of the value of the house for closing costs (including Plum’s Group Success Fee) and 3% of the value of the house for the initial reserve fund.

Mortgage Payment
Total Expenses
This total is an estimate of all the expected costs associated with owning a vacation home with a Plum certified ownership agreement.
Location, type of house, changes in interest rates and utilities can all change and affect the monthly cost throughout the term of ownership.
Monthly Income
Total Monthly Income

A good threshold for rental property investment is the 1% Rule (source). It states that you should only invest in rental property if you are reasonably confident that the property can rent for 1% of the sale price per month.

We’ve included that assumption here. It is critical that the group validate pricing, rental history, and future rental projections of any specific property before proceeding with a purchase. You can explore rental incomes of any property with this free estimation tool at

Sign Up, Learn More

Unlock exclusive features & receive updates

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

© 2024 Plum CoOwnership